• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria: Authentic New York Style Pizza in Rocklin, CA

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria, located on Sunset Blvd in Rocklin, CA, brings authentic New York-style pizza to the West Coast. Known for its perfect balance of tangy, savory red sauce and generous cheese, this family-owned spot crafts pies that rival those in Times Square. The crust is thin yet flavorful, delighting both locals and East Coast visitors alike. While service can sometimes lag, the quality of their pizzas—like classic combos, BBQ chicken, and halal pepperoni—more than makes up for it. For those craving genuine NY pizza with a genuine local touch, Johnny’s is a must-visit for a memorable, crave-worthy experience.

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria at a glance

  • Address 2830 Sunset Blvd, Rocklin, CA 95677, United States
  • Phone +1 916-626-1487
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Amanda Matarazzo
5

Family was in town who grew up on the east coast, so Friday night called for a Johnny’s pizza night! Pictured is a half porky pie half combo, full bbq chicken, and half cheese half halal pepperoni. How do you even pick a favorite? Everyone raved about the pies and crust. The crust had our bulldog foaming at the mouth Thank you Johnny’s NY Pizzeria for a great family pizza night!

Maria Farmer
5

The pizza is so good! I love NY style pizza and this is the best in the area. This is a family owned restaurant and they couldn’t be any nicer. Take out or delivery available.

Josh Cook
4

Pizza is 5 stars, so let's start right there. 4 stars is because of the wait and side order. 1) Garlic Bread was trash, 100%. Definitely not what the pictures show online. Thick dough, huge crest and hat dry. 2) Service has pretty bad. Waited over an hour to service my pizza. Place wasnt busy. And yes, I'm 100% aware of when door dash orders come through. No listed phone number, so no phone orders. With having said all of that, if he want a GREAT GREAT NY style pizza then this is the place to go. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio. Red sauce is the best. Sweet and savory.

C.
5

This is legit NY Pizza! My wife is from the Bronx and we have yet to find pizza in CA that compares to NY, until we stopped at Johnny’s for a cheese slice. This is our new one and only pizza stop.

Beth Abel
5

This is honestly the best pizza I've had in California. It is true New York style and tastes like I'm eating at my favorite place in Times Square! It's a little expensive so it's like our special treat pizza night, but man, it's good.

David Adams
5

Great place, can be difficult to get in and get a pizza so just make it a point to call early. We live in Colfax and had heard about this place a while back. Does NY pizza justice, and I thoroughly enjoyed the employees and owner. Very respectful and helpful. Appreciate them all.

M
5

This place makes great NY style pizza, and at a very good price. The dough/crust is super good and has lots of flavor, with lots of microbubbles and some big ones. The bake is well done in a very hot oven. My only critique compared to what I've had in NYC is that the cheese is a bit much, but that hardly detracts from the pizza—it is still very good. This'll probably be my go-to pizza place in Rocklin from now on. Good work Johnny and team!

Kiki Wong
5

I’ve been looking for a great NY style pizza place that sells by the slice in the area. It has been few and far between, but by far this place is THE BEST I’ve had in a long time. Incredible lunch deal for slices. Proof I couldn’t help eat it before the photo. Crispy throughout the slice and the crust was soft. Great dough and ingredients.

Location

  • Johnny’s NY Pizzeria
    Johnny’s NY Pizzeria
    2830 Sunset Blvd, Rocklin, CA 95677, United States Hotline: +1 916-626-1487

Johnny’s NY Pizzeria stands out as an authentic slice of New York in the heart of Rocklin, California. Located conveniently on Sunset Boulevard, this family-owned pizzeria offers a genuine NY-style pizza experience that has won over locals and East Coast transplants alike. Walking into Johnny’s, you can immediately sense the passion for true, hand-tossed New York crust—thin but sturdy, perfectly crisp along the edges, with that signature foldable texture that defines classic NY pizza.

The highlight here is unmistakably the pizza itself. Each pie boasts a flawless balance of sweet and savory red sauce paired with the ideal cheese-to-sauce ratio, crafted to please even the most discerning pizza purists. Whether you opt for a traditional cheese slice or an adventurous combo, like porky pie or BBQ chicken, the quality shines through. The crust’s aroma and flavor create such an inviting ambiance that even four-legged family members can't resist it, as one satisfied customer noted.

Beyond taste, Johnny’s offers the warmth and attentiveness of a family-run establishment, making every visit feel personal. While some have mentioned wait times and side dish inconsistencies—specifically the garlic bread—the core menu remains unmatched in authenticity and flavor. The absence of phone orders emphasizes their commitment to freshness and in-person crafting, reinforcing their dedication to quality over convenience.

For those craving a true New York pizza experience without leaving California, Johnny’s NY Pizzeria delivers a slice of nostalgia with each bite. It is a place where the traditional essence of East Coast pizza meets local hospitality, creating memorable family pizza nights and becoming a go-to spot for pizza aficionados seeking that genuine taste of the Big Apple.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards